When a new genre of TV show is released, fans always compare it to the most successful example of that format. Almost every big-budget, sword-swinging series since 2011 has been compared toGame of Thronesat one point in time (the current contender is FX’sShogun). The same applies to video game adaptations, with Prime Video’sFalloutthe latest in the recent boom of episodic adaptations.
After 30 years of terrible live-action video game adaptations (starting withSuper Mario Bros.in 1993), HBO’sThe Last of Uscracked the code in 2023, bringing Naughty Dog’s acclaimed video game series to life. The show received stellar reviews from critics and won eight Primetime Emmys. Prime Video’sFalloutreceived similar reviews from critics and, as was expected, was immediately compared to HBO’sThe Last of Us.However, comparing the shows does a disservice to both and ultimately undermines the work put into adapting each show from their respective video games.
Fallout and The Last of Us Are Very Different Types of Video Games
Read Our Review
Prime Video’sFalloutandThe Last of Usshare many similarities. Both are based on critically acclaimed, award-winning video game franchises. Both feature incredible casts and are helmed by incredibly talented writers, producers, directors, and showrunners. Their respective video games also share some similarities, namely theirpost-apocalyptic settingsand the inclusion of zombie-like creatures. However, that is where the similarities between the two stop.
Naughty Dog’sThe Last of Usis a linear, survival-based horror game. Players switch between Joel and Ellie across a tightly written, single-thread narrative that confines players to the parameters of its main plot. Meanwhile, Bethesda and Obsidian’sFalloutgames take place in sprawling, open worlds, with RPG (Role Playing Games) elements that bestow narrative freedom on the players.
Falloutplayers create their own characters and dictate their own stories by choosing dialogue options and selecting which factions and characters to side with in a game with a multitude of different endings. This isn’t to say that either game is better than the other because of its narrative and gameplay structure.However, adapting each game into an episodic series is vastly different because of their gameplay style.
Fallout Director Jonathan Nolan and Co-Creator Graham Wagner on Their Big Gamble and Finding Great Stories in Video Games
The creative duo dives into the thrill of creating their live-action series, and how The Ghoul was written specifically with Walton Goggins in mind.
The Last of Us' confined, linear narrative (roughly told over 14 hours) feels like it was tailor-made for a television adaptation. The game’s story structure, spread over 12 chapters, can be directly translated into an episodic format. The show’s creators, Neil Druckmann and Craig Mazin were then tasked with manipulating the story (adding and removing necessary elements) to better fit the structure of a 9-episode series.
In some regards, adaptingThe Last of Usis akin to adapting a popular novel, albeit with added visual references. Meanwhile,Fallout’s open-worldand open-ended storytelling posed potential problems for Graham Wagner, Geneva Robertson-Dworet, and Jonathan Nolan. Were they to directly adapt any of the games' stories, it would risk excluding a large portion of the fan base who may have taken that game’s narrative in a different direction – especially considering the show is canon within the franchise’s lore. As a result, the creative trio created a completely original story with brand-new characters set in the same universe as the games.
As a result, attempting to compare both shows from the perspective of their success at adapting their respective games is as futile as it is unfair to their creative teams. Many scenes and even lines of dialogue inThe Last of Usare taken one-for-one from the video game. Meanwhile,Falloutcould take visual cues and design concepts from the games but had a blank canvas (albeit within the confines of the games' past lore) to create a new show.Both processes have pros and cons, and comparing the quality of both shows is like comparing their video game counterparts against each other.
However, while comparisons between the two shows are unfair,Fallout’s creative team isn’t ignorantabout the success ofThe Last of Usand how it opened the door for their adaptation. Jonathan Nolan praised HBO’s series and addressed how it has changed the future landscape of video game adaptations. Nolan said, “When Todd [Howard,Fallout’s developer] and I first sat down for lunch, the bar was not only not high, it was nonexistent — especially in the TV space… But when somebody makes something as good asThe Last of Us, it makes it easier, because suddenly everyone understands what’s possible.”
Fallout and The Last of Us Have Set Up More Video Game Adaptations
Whether you preferred HBO’sThe Last of Usor Prime Video’sFalloutor liked both shows equally, they have left a lasting impression on thefuture of video game adaptations.For years, fans had thought TV was the perfect format for video game adaptations, considering their mission-based structure, and shows likeThe Last of UsandFallouthave proven this to be true.
Fallout Game Director Shares Disappointing View on Other Adaptations After Prime Video Show Success
Fallout’s game director Todd Howard says an Elder Scrolls adaptation isn’t happening anytime soon.
Of course, new movies like theSonic the Hedgehogfranchise, and the newSuper Mario Bros. Moviehave proven that video game movies can work, transforming these games into episodic shows has a much higher success rate. Even beforeThe Last of Us, Netflix had tremendous success adapting the belovedCastlevaniafranchise into an animated show. They quickly followed this up withArcane, based on theLeague of Legendsgame. Their most recent success isCyberpunk: Edgerunners, an anime tie-in to CDProjektRed’sCyberpunkgame.
As you might expect, followingThe Last of UsandFallout’s success, a whole host of new video game adaptations are on the way. Some have been in the works for a while, like Paramount+‘sKnucklesseries, which follows from the success of theSonic the Hedgehogmovies. Others were announced inthe wake ofThe Last of Us’s success, like Prime Video’s hotly anticipatedGod of Warseries.
Falloutwon’t be the only video game adaptation released in 2024, either. Alongside theKnucklesseries, Season 2 of Netflix’sArcaneis expected to release in November. Netflix’s animatedTomb Raider: The Legend of Lara Croftis also slated to release later this year. In the realm of feature films,BorderlandsandSonic the Hedgehog 3are also scheduled to hit theaters this year.Falloutis streaming now onPrime Video.The Last of Usis streaming onMax.
